Defining the Spatial Resolution Requirements for Crop Identification Using Optical Remote Sensing
Abstract
The past decades have seen an increasing demand for operational monitoring of crop conditions and food production at local to global scales. To properly use satellite Earth observation for such agricultural monitoring, high temporal revisit frequency over vast geographic areas is necessary. However, this often limits the spatial resolution that can be used. The challenge of discriminating pixels that correspond to a particular crop type, a prerequisite for crop specific agricultural monitoring, remains daunting when the signal encoded in pixels stems from several land uses (mixed pixels), e.g., over heterogeneous landscapes where individual fields are often smaller than individual pixels. The question of determining the optimal pixel sizes for an application such as crop identification is therefore naturally inclined towards finding the coarsest acceptable pixel sizes, so as to potentially benefit from what instruments with coarser pixels can offer. To answer this question, this study builds upon and extends a conceptual framework to quantitatively define pixel size requirements for crop identification via image classification. This tool can be modulated using different parameterizations to explore trade-offs between pixel size and pixel purity when addressing the question of crop identification. Results over contrasting landscapes in Central Asia demonstrate that the task of finding the optimum pixel size does not have a ``one-size-fits-all'' solution. The resulting values for pixel size and purity that are suitable for crop identification proved to be specific to a given landscape, and for each crop they differed across different landscapes. Over the same time series, different crops were not identifiable simultaneously in the season and these requirements further changed over the years, reflecting the different agro-ecological conditions the crops are growing in. Results indicate that sensors like MODIS (250 m) could be suitable for identifying major crop classes in the study sites, whilst sensors like Landsat (30 m) should be considered for object-based classification. The proposed framework is generic and can be applied to any agricultural landscape, thereby potentially serving to guide recommendations for designing dedicated EO missions that can satisfy the requirements in terms of pixel size to identify and discriminate crop types.
Keywords
crop identification; crop monitoring; pixel purity; pixel size; time series; RapidEye
Related pages
-
ASSESSMENT OF CLASSIFICATION ACCURACIES OF SENTINEL-2 AND LANDSAT-8 DATA FOR LAND COVER / USE MAPPING
Author: Topaloğlu, Raziye Hale and Sertel, Elif and Musaoğlu, Nebiye -
COMBINED ANALYSIS OF SENTINEL-1 AND RAPIDEYE DATA FOR IMPROVED CROP TYPE CLASSIFICATION: AN EARLY SEASON APPROACH FOR RAPESEED AND CEREALS
Author: Lussem, U. and Hütt, C. and Waldhoff, G. -
COMPARISON OF UNCALIBRATED RGBVI WITH SPECTROMETER-BASED NDVI DERIVED FROM UAV SENSING SYSTEMS ON FIELD SCALE
Author: Bareth, G. and Bolten, A. and Gnyp, M. L. and Reusch, S. and Jasper, J. -
Crop Monitoring Based on SPOT-5 Take-5 and Sentinel-1A Data for the Estimation of Crop Water Requirements
Author: Navarro, Ana and Rolim, João and Miguel, Irina and Catalão, João and Silva, Joel and Painho, Marco and Vekerdy, Zoltán -
Improved Early Crop Type Identification By Joint Use of High Temporal Resolution SAR And Optical Image Time Series
Author: Inglada, Jordi and Vincent, Arthur and Arias, Marcela and Marais-Sicre, Claire -
OBJECT-BASED CLASSIFICATION AND CHANGE DETECTION OF HOKKAIDO, JAPAN
Author: Park, J. G. and Harada, I. and Kwak, Y. -
RICE YIELD ESTIMATION THROUGH ASSIMILATING SATELLITE DATA INTO A CROP SIMUMLATION MODEL
Author: Son, N. T. and Chen, C. F. and Chen, C. R. and Chang, L. Y. and Chiang, S. H. -
Semi-supervised multiview feature selection with label learning for VHR remote sensing images
Author: Chen, Xi and Liu, Wei and Su, Fulin and Shao, Guofan -
USING LANDSAT 8 IMAGE TIME SERIES FOR CROP MAPPING IN A REGION OF CERRADO, BRAZIL
Author: Bendini, H. and Sanches, I. D. and Körting, T. S. and Fonseca, L. M. G. and Luiz, A. J. B. and Formaggio, A. R. -
A Framework for Defining Spatially Explicit Earth Observation Requirements for a Global Agricultural Monitoring Initiative (GEOGLAM)
Author: Whitcraft, Alyssa and Becker-Reshef, Inbal and Justice, Christopher -
A Generic Algorithm to Estimate LAI, FAPAR and FCOVER Variables from SPOT4_HRVIR and Landsat Sensors: Evaluation of the Consistency and Comparison with Ground Measurements
Author: Li, Wenjuan and Weiss, Marie and Waldner, Francois and Defourny, Pierre and Demarez, Valerie and Morin, David and Hagolle, Olivier and Baret, Frederic -
An Automated Method for Annual Cropland Mapping along the Season for Various Globally-Distributed Agrosystems Using High Spatial and Temporal Resolution Time Series
Author: Matton, Nicolas and Canto, Guadalupe and Waldner, François and Valero, Silvia and Morin, David and Inglada, Jordi and Arias, Marcela and Bontemps, Sophie and Koetz, Benjamin and Defourny, Pierre -
Assessment of an Operational System for Crop Type Map Production Using High Temporal and Spatial Resolution Satellite Optical Imagery
Author: Inglada, Jordi and Arias, Marcela and Tardy, Benjamin and Hagolle, Olivier and Valero, Silvia and Morin, David and Dedieu, Gérard and Sepulcre, Guadalupe and Bontemps, Sophie and Defourny, Pierre and Koetz, Benjamin -
Characteristics of Landsat 8 OLI-derived NDVI by comparison with multiple satellite sensors and in-situ observations
Author: Ke, Yinghai and Im, Jungho and Lee, Junghee and Gong, Huili and Ryu, Youngryel -
Conditional Random Fields for Multitemporal and Multiscale Classification of Optical Satellite Imagery
Author: Hoberg, Thorsten and Rottensteiner, Franz and Queiroz Feitosa, Raul and Heipke, Christian -
Crop Ground Cover Fraction and Canopy Chlorophyll Content Mapping using RapidEye imagery
Author: Zillmann, E. and Schönert, M and Lilienthal, H. and Siegmann, B. and Jarmer, T and Rosso, P. and Weichelt, T. -
Crop mapping applications at scale: Using Google Earth Engine to enable global crop area and status monitoring using free and open data sources
Author: Lemoine, Guido and Leo, Olivier -
Dynamical Approach for Real-Time Monitoring of Agricultural Crops
Author: Vicente-Guijalba, Fernando and Martinez-Marin, Tomas and Lopez-Sanchez, Juan M. -
Evaluating Multispectral Images and Vegetation Indices for Precision Farming Applications from UAV Images
Author: Candiago, Sebastian and Remondino, Fabio and De Giglio, Michaela and Dubbini, Marco and Gattelli, Mario -
Image Segmentation Based on Constrained Spectral Variance Difference and Edge Penalty
Author: Chen, Bo and Qiu, Fang and Wu, Bingfang and Du, Hongyue -
Improving the Spatial Resolution of Landsat TM/ETM+ Through Fusion With SPOT5 Images via Learning-Based Super-Resolution
Author: Song, Huihui and Huang, Bo and Liu, Qingshan and Zhang, Kaihua -
Intercomparison of UAV, Aircraft and Satellite Remote Sensing Platforms for Precision Viticulture
Author: Matese, Alessandro and Toscano, Piero and Di Gennaro, Salvatore and Genesio, Lorenzo and Vaccari, Francesco and Primicerio, Jacopo and Belli, Claudio and Zaldei, Alessandro and Bianconi, Roberto and Gioli, Beniamino -
Land Cover and Crop Type Classification along the Season Based on Biophysical Variables Retrieved from Multi-Sensor High-Resolution Time Series
Author: Waldner, François and Lambert, Marie-Julie and Li, Wenjuan and Weiss, Marie and Demarez, Valérie and Morin, David and Marais-Sicre, Claire and Hagolle, Olivier and Baret, Frédéric and Defourny, Pierre -
Mapping Cropland in Smallholder-Dominated Savannas: Integrating Remote Sensing Techniques and Probabilistic Modeling
Author: Sweeney, Sean and Ruseva, Tatyana and Estes, Lyndon and Evans, Tom -
Mapping of Agricultural Crops from Single High-Resolution Multispectral Images—Data-Driven Smoothing vs. Parcel-Based Smoothing
Author: Ozdarici-Ok, Asli and Ok, Ali and Schindler, Konrad -
Mapping Priorities to Focus Cropland Mapping Activities: Fitness Assessment of Existing Global, Regional and National Cropland Maps
Author: Waldner, François and Fritz, Steffen and Di Gregorio, Antonio and Defourny, Pierre -
Mapping spatial variability of crop growth conditions using RapidEye data in Northern Ontario, Canada
Author: Shang, Jiali and Liu, Jiangui and Ma, Baoluo and Zhao, Ting and Jiao, Xianfeng and Geng, Xiaoyuan and Huffman, Ted and Kovacs, John M. and Walters, Dan -
Multispectral image fusion based on joint sparse subspace recovery
Author: Liao, Bin and Liu, Wenzhao and Shen, Jing -
On the use of temporal-spectral descriptors for crop mapping, monitoring and crop practices characterization
Author: Holecz, Francesco and Gatti, Luca and Collivignarelli, Francesco and Barbieri, Massimo -
Parcel based classification for agricultural mapping and monitoring using multi-temporal satellite image sequences
Author: Kussul, Nataliia and Lemoine, Guido and Gallego, Javier and Skakun, Sergii and Lavreniuk, Mykola -
Regional scale crop mapping using multi-temporal satellite imagery
Author: Kussul, N. and Skakun, S. and Shelestov, A. and Lavreniuk, M. and Yailymov, B. and Kussul, O. -
Reliable Crop Identification with Satellite Imagery in the Context of Common Agriculture Policy Subsidy Control
Author: Schmedtmann, Jonas and Campagnolo, Manuel -
Rice Fields Mapping in Fragmented Area Using Multi-Temporal HJ-1A/B CCD Images
Author: Wang, Jing and Huang, Jingfeng and Zhang, Kangyu and Li, Xinxing and She, Bao and Wei, Chuanwen and Gao, Jian and Song, Xiaodong -
Rice yield estimation using Landsat ETM+ Data
Author: Siyal, Altaf Ali and Dempewolf, Jan and Becker-Reshef, Inbal -
Spatial segmentation of multi/hyperspectral imagery by fusion of spectral-gradient-textural attributes
Author: Vantaram, Sreenath Rao and Piramanayagam, Sankaranarayanan and Saber, Eli and Messinger, David -
SPOT-Based Sub-Field Level Monitoring of Vegetation Cover Dynamics: A Case of Irrigated Croplands
Author: Dubovyk, Olena and Menz, Gunter and Lee, Alexander and Schellberg, Juergen and Thonfeld, Frank and Khamzina, Asia -
Technology targeting for sustainable intensification of crop production in the Delta region of Bangladesh
Author: Schulthess, U. and Krupnik, T. J. and Ahmed, Z. U. and McDonald, A. J. -
The Tasseled Cap Transformation for RapidEye data and the estimation of vital and senescent crop parameters
Author: Schönert, M. and Zillmann, E. and Weichelt, H. and Eitel, J.U.H. and Magney, T.S. and Lilienthal, H. and Siegmann, B. and Jarmer, T. -
A Comparative Study on Satellite- and Model-Based Crop Phenology in West Africa
Author: Vintrou, Elodie and Bégué, Agnès and Baron, Christian and Saad, Alexandre and Lo Seen, Danny and Traoré, Seydou -
A Lightweight Hyperspectral Mapping System and Photogrammetric Processing Chain for Unmanned Aerial Vehicles
Author: Suomalainen, Juha and Anders, Niels and Iqbal, Shahzad and Roerink, Gerbert and Franke, Jappe and Wenting, Philip and Hünniger, Dirk and Bartholomeus, Harm and Becker, Rolf and Kooistra, Lammert -
An Airborne Multispectral Imaging System Based on Two Consumer-Grade Cameras for Agricultural Remote Sensing
Author: Yang, Chenghai and Westbrook, John and Suh, Charles and Martin, Daniel and Hoffmann, W. and Lan, Yubin and Fritz, Bradley and Goolsby, John -
An assessment of pre- and within-season remotely sensed variables for forecasting corn and soybean yields in the United States
Author: Johnson, David M. -
Automatic Training Sample Selection for a Multi-Evidence Based Crop Classification Approach
Author: Chellasamy, M. and Ty Ferre, P. A. and Humlekrog Greve, M. -
Chosen problems with acquiring multispectral imagery data using the miniMCA camera
Author: Rafal Dabrowski and Agata Orych -
Classification of small agricultural fields using combined Landsat-8 and RapidEye imagery: case study of northern Serbia
Author: Crnojevic, Vladimir and Lugonja, Predrag and Brkljac, Branko and Brunet, Borislav -
Comparison of Eight Techniques for Reconstructing Multi-Satellite Sensor Time-Series NDVI Data Sets in the Heihe River Basin, China
Author: Geng, Liying and Ma, Mingguo and Wang, Xufeng and Yu, Wenping and Jia, Shuzhen and Wang, Haibo -
Continuous Change Detection and Classification of Land Cover Using all Available Landsat Data
Author: Zhe Zhu and Curtis E. Woodcock -
Crop Type Classification by Simultaneous Use of Satellite Images of Different Resolutions
Author: Liu, Mark W. and Ozdogan, Mutlu and Zhu, Xiaojin -
Deriving crop calendar using NDVI time-series
Author: Patel, J. H. and Oza, M. P. -
Development and assessment of leaf area index algorithms for the Sentinel-2 multispectral imager
Author: Fernandes, Richard and Weiss, Marie and Camacho, Fernando and Berthelot, Beatrice and Baret, Fred and Duca, Riccardo -
Development of a Remote Sensing-Based ``Boro'' Rice Mapping System
Author: Mosleh, Mostafa K., and Hassan, Quazi K. -
Empirical Regression Models for Estimating Multiyear Leaf Area Index of Rice from Several Vegetation Indices at the Field Scale
Author: Maki, Masayasu and Homma, Koki -
From Remotely Sensed Vegetation Onset to Sowing Dates: Aggregating Pixel-Level Detections into Village-Level Sowing Probabilities
Author: Marinho, Eduardo and Vancutsem, Christelle and Fasbender, Dominique and Kayitakire, François and Pini, Giancarlo and Pekel, Jean-François -
How Reliable is the MODIS Land Cover Product for Crop Mapping Sub-Saharan Agricultural Landscapes?
Author: Leroux, Louise and Jolivot, Audrey and Bégué, Agnès and Seen, Danny Lo and Zoungrana, Bernardin -
Investigating the Relationship between the Inter-annual Variability of Satellite-derived Vegetation Phenology and a Proxy of Biomass Production in the Sahel
Author: Meroni, Michele and Rembold, Felix and Verstraete, Michel M. and Gommes, Rene and Schucknecht, Anne and Beye, Gora -
Knowledge-based approach for VHR satellite image time series analysis
Author: Rejichi, S. and Chaabane, F. -
Mapping irrigated areas in Afghanistan over the past decade using MODIS NDVI
Author: Shahriar Pervez, Md. and Budde, Michael and Rowland, James -
Near real time yield estimation for sugarcane in Brazil combining remote sensing and official statistical data
Author: Pupin Mello, Marcio and Atzberger, Clement and Formaggio, Antonio Roberto -
Operationalizing crop monitoring system for informed decision making related to food security in Nepal
Author: Qamer, F. M. and Shah, S. N. Pd. and Murthy, M. S. R. and Baidar, T. and Dhonju, K. and Hari, B. G. -
Phenological growth stages of paddy rice according to the BBCH scale and SAR images
Author: Erten, Esra and Rossi, Cristian and Yuzugullu, Onur and Hajnsek, Irena -
Relationship between fraction of radiation absorbed by photosynthesizing maize and soybean canopies and NDVI from remotely sensed data taken at close range and from MODIS 250m resolution data
Author: Gitelson, Anatoly A. and Peng, Yi and Huemmrich, Karl F. -
Separating Crop Species in Northeastern Ontario Using Hyperspectral Data
Author: Wilson, Jeffrey and Zhang, Chunhua and Kovacs, John -
The Estimation of Regional Crop Yield Using Ensemble-Based Four-Dimensional Variational Data Assimilation
Author: Jiang, Zhiwei and Chen, Zhongxin and Chen, Jin and Ren, Jianqiang and Li, Zongnan and Sun, Liang -
The Potential and Uptake of Remote Sensing in Insurance: A Review
Author: de Leeuw, Jan and Vrieling, Anton and Shee, Apurba and Atzberger, Clement and Hadgu, Kiros M. and Biradar, Chandrashekhar M. and Keah, Humphrey and Turvey, Calum -
Use of Smartphone to Derive the Leaf Area Index
Author: Najafabadi, Masih Rajaei -
Vicarious Radiometric Calibration of a Multispectral Camera on Board an Unmanned Aerial System
Author: Del Pozo, Susana and Rodríguez-Gonzálvez, Pablo and Hernández-López, David and Felipe-García, Beatriz -
A Phenology-Based Classification of Time-Series MODIS Data for Rice Crop Monitoring in Mekong Delta, Vietnam
Author: Son, Nguyen-Thanh and Chen, Chi-Farn and Chen, Cheng-Ru and Duc, Huynh-Ngoc and Chang, Ly-Yu -
Advances in Remote Sensing of Agriculture: Context Description, Existing Operational Monitoring Systems and Major Information Needs
Author: Atzberger, Clement -
CONTEXTUAL IMAGE CLASSIFICATION APPROACH FOR MONITORING OF AGRICULTURAL LAND COVER BY SUPPORT VECTOR MACHINES AND MARKOV RANDOM FIELDS
Author: Vahidi, H. and Monabbati, E. -
Gaussian Processes Uncertainty Estimates in Experimental Sentinel-2 LAI and Leaf Chlorophyll Content Retrieval
Author: Jochem Verrelst and Juan Pablo Rivera and José Moreno and Gustavo Camps-Valls -
HIGH RESOLUTION TEMPORAL NORMALIZED DIFFERENCE VEGETATION INDICES FOR SPECIFIC CROP IDENTIFICATION
Author: Upadhyay, P. and Ghosh, S. K. and Kumar, A. -
Identification of agricultural crops in early stages using remote sensing images
Author: Valero, Silvia and Ceccato, Pietro and Baethgen, Walter E. and Chanussot, Jocelyn -
Impact of Feature Selection on the Accuracy and Spatial Uncertainty of Per-field Crop Classification using Support Vector Machines
Author: Löw, F. and Michel, U. and Dech, S. and Conrad, C. -
Mapping cropping intensity of smallholder farms: A comparison of methods using multiple sensors
Author: Jain, Meha and Mondal, Pinki and DeFries, Ruth S. and Small, Christopher and Galford, Gillian L. -
Method for reconstructing the pixel missing region on remote sensing images
Author: Fan, Weiliang and Ju, Weimin and Gu, Zhujun -
RESEARCH ON ESTIMATION CROP PLANTING AREA BY INTEGRATING THE OPTICAL AND MICROWAVE REMOTE SENSING DATA
Author: Jia, Y. and Yu, F. -
Satellite-based Investigation of Flood-affected Rice Cultivation Areas in Chao Phraya River Delta, Thailand
Author: N.T. Son and C.F. Chen and C.R. Chen and L.Y. Chang -
Scientific documentation of crop land changes in the Sahel: A half empty box of knowledge to support policy?
Author: van Vliet, Nathalie and Reenberg, Anette and Rasmussen, Laura Vang -
Urban vegetation classification: Benefits of multitemporal RapidEye satellite data
Author: Tigges, Jan and Lakes, Tobia and Hostert, Patrick -
Agricultural land use mapping in the sudanian savanna of West Africa: Current status and future possibilities
Author: Forkuor, Gerald and Landmann, Tobias and Conrad, Christopher and Dech, Stefan -
An Automated Cropland Classification Algorithm (ACCA) for Tajikistan by Combining Landsat, MODIS, and Secondary Data
Author: Thenkabail, Prasad S. and Wu, Zhuoting -
Automatic Detection and Segmentation of Orchards Using Very High Resolution Imagery
Author: Aksoy, Selim and Yalniz, Ismet Zeki and Tasdemir, Kadim -
Crop area estimation in Ukraine using satellite data within the MARS project
Author: Kussul, Nataliia and Skakun, Sergii and Shelestov, Andrii and Kravchenko, Oleksii and Gallego, Javier Francisco and Kussul, Olga -
Integrative use of multitemporal rapideye and TerraSAR-X data for agricultural monitoring
Author: Bach, Heike and Friese, Malin and Spannraft, Katharina and Migdall, Silke and Dotzler, Sandra and Hank, Tobias and Frank, Toni and Mauser, Wolfram -
MAPPING CROP STATUS FROM AN UNMANNED AERIAL VEHICLE FOR PRECISION AGRICULTURE APPLICATIONS
Author: Guo, T. and Kujirai, T. and Watanabe, T. -
Mapping Cropland Distributions Using a Hard and Soft Classification Model
Author: Pan, Yaozhong and Hu, Tangao and Zhu, Xiufang and Zhang, Jinshui and Wang, Xiaodong -
Mapping paddy rice agriculture in a highly fragmented area using a geographic information system object-based post classification process
Author: Lin, Meng-Lung and Lin, Meng-Lung and Huang, Chao-Hsiung and Chu, Tzu-How -
Multi-temporal remote sensing image segmentation of croplands constrained by a topographical database
Author: Inglada, Jordi and Dejoux, Jean-Francois and Hagolle, Olivier and Dedieu, Gerard -
Optimal Exploitation of the Sentinel-2 Spectral Capabilities for Crop Leaf Area Index Mapping
Author: Richter, Katja and Hank, Tobias B. and Vuolo, Francesco and Mauser, Wolfram and D'Urso, Guido -
SUPPORT VECTOR MACHINE CLASSIFICATION OF OBJECT-BASED DATA FOR CROP MAPPING, USING MULTI-TEMPORAL LANDSAT IMAGERY
Author: Devadas, R. and Denham, R. J. and Pringle, M. -
TEMPORAL INDICES DATA FOR SPECIFIC CROP DISCRIMINATION USING FUZZY BASED NOISE CLASSIFIER
Author: Musande, V. and Kumar, A. and Kale, K. and Roy, P. S. -
Absolute Radiometric Calibration of the RapidEye Multispectral Imager Using the Reflectance-based Vicarious Calibration Method
Author: Naughton, Denis and Brunn, Andreas and Czapla-Myers, Jeff and Douglass, Scott and Thiele, Michael and Weichelt, Horst and Oxfort, Michael -
Comparison of different vegetation indices for the remote assessment of green leaf area index of crops
Author: Viña, Andrés and Gitelson, Anatoly A. and Nguy-Robertson, Anthony L. and Peng, Yi -
Downscaling Pesticide Use Data to the Crop Field Level in California Using Landsat Satellite Imagery: Paraquat Case Study
Author: Maxwell, Susan K. -
Improved method for discriminating agricultural crops using geostatistics and remote sensing
Author: Fiorentino, Costanza and Tarantino, Cristina and Pasquariello, Guido and Basso, Bruno -
Mapping double-cropped irrigated rice fields in Taiwan using time-series Satellite Pour I'Observation de la Terre data
Author: Chen, Chi-Farn and Huang, Su-Wei and Son, Nguyen-Thanh and Chang, Li-Yu -
Multispectral Remote Sensing from Unmanned Aircraft: Image Processing Workflows and Applications for Rangeland Environments
Author: Laliberte, Andrea S. and Goforth, Mark A. and Steele, Caitriana M. and Rango, Albert -
Shifting farming–pastoral ecotone in China under climate and land use changes
Author: Liu, Jun-hui and Gao, Ji-xi and Lu, Shi-Hai and Han, Yong-wei and Nie, Yi-huang -
Using active learning to adapt remote sensing image classifiers
Author: Tuia, D. and Pasolli, E. and Emery, W.J. -
Virtual Interpretation of Earth Web-Interface Tool (VIEW-IT) for Collecting Land-Use/Land-Cover Reference Data
Author: Clark, Matthew L. and Aide, T. Mitchell -
Current Status and Future Directions of Precision Aerial Application for Site-Specific Crop Management in the USA
Author: Lan, Yubin and Thomson, Steven J. and Huang, Yanbo and Hoffmann, W. Clint and Zhang, Huihui - Algorithmic approaches
- Automated image processing workflow
- Crop identification
- RapidEye/Blackbridge
- Sentinel satellites